Ways to change your Medigap policy in Oklahoma
| Situation | Health questions? | What you can buy |
|---|---|---|
| Within 60 days starting on your birthday (birthday rule) | No | Same or lesser benefits, any company |
| Your Medigap company goes bankrupt or misled you | No | Certain plans, within 63 days after coverage ends |
| Any other time, or a plan with more benefits | Yes, the company can ask | Whatever the company approves |
The birthday rule is in OAC 365:10-5-129(f), effective September 1, 2023. To use it you must have had Medigap coverage with no gap longer than 90 days. OID's chart shows, for example, that a Plan G holder can move to Plan A, B, D, G, K, L, M or N, or a high-deductible F or G, and a Plan N holder can move to Plan M or N. See the full chart on does Oklahoma have a Medigap birthday rule.
Common reasons Oklahomans switch
- Price. Plans with the same letter have the same standardized benefits from every company, so switching to the same letter at a lower premium changes the price, not the coverage.
- Fewer benefits. Some people move from Plan G to Plan N to lower their premium in exchange for some copays.
- Company service. You can move to a different company under the birthday rule.
How to switch safely
- Check your birthday window. Apply within the 60 days that start on your birthday to avoid health questions.
- Apply for the new policy first. Don't cancel the old one yet.
- Wait for approval and a start date. Coverage usually starts on the first of the month after the company accepts your application.
- Cancel the old policy in writing. Do it once the new policy is in force, and keep a copy.
Don't let anyone rush you into dropping a policy. If someone misleads you to get you to switch, you can file a complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Department at 800-522-0071.
To compare Medigap policies from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent. See Medigap in Oklahoma.
Related questions
When can I buy Medigap in Oklahoma?
Every window, in one place.
Switching from Medicare Advantage to Medigap
When health questions apply.
Can I get Medigap under 65?
Oklahoma's disability rule.
Sources
- Oklahoma Insurance Department — New Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment FAQs and plan options chart
- Oklahoma Insurance Department — Bulletin No. 10-2023 (Revised)
- Oklahoma Insurance Department — Medicare Supplement Buyer's Guide
- Medicare.gov — Can I switch or drop my Medigap policy?
More questions in this guide
- Can I get a Medicare supplement under 65 in Oklahoma?
- Can I switch from Medicare Advantage to a Medicare supplement in Oklahoma?
- Does Oklahoma have a Medigap birthday rule?
- When can I buy a Medicare supplement in Oklahoma?
Part of the guide: Medigap (Medicare Supplement) in Oklahoma · All questions
Frequently asked questions
Does Medicare's fall open enrollment let me switch Medigap plans?
No. The October 15 to December 7 open enrollment period is for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans. Medigap switching in Oklahoma follows the birthday rule and federal guaranteed-issue rights instead.
Will I lose credit for the Part B deductible if I switch mid-year?
The Part B deductible is a calendar-year amount and doesn't reset when you change policies, the Oklahoma Insurance Department says, but your new plan may not cover it. High-deductible plans' deductibles may restart with a new policy, so ask the company.
Can my company raise my premium?
Yes. Medigap premiums can go up, and attained-age policies also rise as you get older. Oklahoma's birthday rule gives you a yearly chance to shop for a lower price for the same or lesser benefits.
Can I return a new policy if I change my mind?
Yes. The Oklahoma Insurance Department's buyer's guide describes a 30-day period to review a new Medicare supplement policy and return it for a refund. Keep your old policy until you're sure.
Medicare in your Oklahoma county
Plans, local agents and help, county by county: Oklahoma · Tulsa · Cleveland · Canadian · Comanche · Rogers · Wagoner · Payne · Pottawatomie · Creek · Muskogee · Garfield · Grady · Washington · Logan · Bryan · Le Flore · Carter · Cherokee · McClain · All 77 counties →